Artificial Intelligence in Law Enforcement and Justice Bodies: Domestic and European Experience
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32353/khrife.4.2022.02Keywords:
artificial intelligence; criminalistics; criminalistic knowledge; specific expertise; digital criminalistics; forensic examination; digital evidence; war crimes investigation; crime prevention; trends in the development of criminalistics.Abstract
The primary concerns of this research paper are to reveal current issues of the application of artificial intelligence technologies in law enforcement and justice bodies in the conditions of martial law and global threats; to identify the main trends, issues and forensic research prospects using artificial intelligence through the prism of European integration processes; to highlight gaps in the normative and legal regulation of the use of digital technologies; outline directions for its improvement. In order to reach objectives, general scientific and special methods (in particular, dialectical, analytical, induction and deduction, and others) were applied. The domestic and European experience in the application of artificial intelligence technologies in law enforcement and justice bodies was analyzed, and their promising directions were determined. We consider that legal regulation of the application of artificial intelligence in Ukraine should be carried out according to European standards, rules and recommendations in accordance with the European integration course chosen by our state. Note that introduction of the artificial intelligence into legal proceedings should be based preliminary on the principles of the rule of law, observance of basic human rights, respect for honor and dignity, equality before the law and the court, proportionality, competition between the parties, transparency, impartiality and justice. Artificial intelligence is not capable of completely replacing judges, however, its implementation will contribute to the optimization of the work of the judge and court. It is substantiated that in today’s military realities, the issue on increasing the effectiveness of the investigation of modern war crimes and cybercrimes with the help of digital technologies has become acute.
References
A definition of Artificial Intelligence: main capabilities and scientific disciplines / European Commission. 08 April 2019. URL: https://digital-strategy.ec.europa. eu/en/library/def inition-artif icial-intelligence-main-capabilities-and-scientific-disciplines.
Ackermann, V. R., Kurapka, V. E., Malewski, H., Shepitko, V. (2020). Schaffung eines einheitlichen europaisehen Kriniinalistischen Raumes: Die Tatigkeit offentlicher Organisationen zur Starkung der internationalen Beziehungen. Kriminalistik. Is. 6.
Avdieieva, H. K. (2020). Problemy vykorystannia system shtuchnoho intelektu v roboti orhaniv kryminalnoi yustytsii [Issues of using artificial intelligence systems in the work of criminal justice bodies]. Vykorystannia tekhnolohii shtuchnoho intelektu u protydii zlochynnosti : mat-ly nauk.-prakt. onlay-seminaru (Kharkiv, 05.11.2020). Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].
Baltrūnienė, J. (2022). Dirbtinis intelektas ir duomenų apsauga kriminalistikos plėtros kontekste / Kriminalistikos teorijos plėtra ir teismo ekspertologijos ateitis: liber amicorum profesoriui Egidijui Vidmantui Kurapkai. Kolektyvinė monografija. Vilnius, 2022 [in Lithuanian].
Baltrūnienė, J., Shevchuk, V. (2022). Artificial Intelligence Technologies in Law Enforcement and Justice: Ukrainian and European experience. Tsyfrova transformatsiia kryminalnoho provadzhennia v umovakh voiennoho stanu : mat-ly Vseukr. kruhloho stolu (Kharkiv, 16.12.2022). Kharkiv.
Baranov, O. (2018). Identyfikatsiia robota zi shtuchnym intelektom yak subiekta prava [Identification of robot with artificial intelligence as a subject of law]. Internet rechey: problemy pravovoho rehuliuvannia ta vprovadzhennia : mat-ly druh. nauk.-prakt. konf. (Kyiv, 29.11.2018). Kyiv, 2018. URL: http://ippi.org.ua/sites/default/ files/zbirnik_tez_19.12.2018-maket_3-converted.pdf [in Ukrainian].
Baranov, O. A. (2018). Internet rechey: teoretyko-metodolohichni osnovy pravovoho rehuliuvannia. T. 1: Sfery zastosuvannia, ryzyky i bariery, problemy pravovoho rehuliuvannia [Internet of things: theoretical and methodological foundations of legal regulation. V 1: Fields of application, risks and barriers, problems of legal regulation]: monohrafiia. Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].
Baranov, O. A. (2019). Pravovi aspekty natsionalnykh stratehiy rozvytku shtuchnoho intelektu [Legal aspects of national strategies for the development of artificial intelligence]. Yurydychna Ukraina. № 7 [in Ukrainian].
Bilous, V. V. (2016). Rol zasobiv kryminalistyky u protydii kiberzlochynnosti [Role of forensic tools in countering cybercrime]. Mizhnarodni standarty z kiberbezpeky ta ikh zastosuvannia v Ukraini : mat-ly «kruhl. stolu» (Kharkiv, 19.04.2016). Kharkiv. URL: http://dspace.nlu.edu.ua/ handle/123456789/10885 [in Ukrainian].
Bugera, O. I. (2021). Use of artificial intelligence to prevent crime. Scientific notes of Taurida National V. I. Vernadsky University. Series: Juridical Sciences. Т. 32 (71). № 6. DOI: 10.32838/TNU-2707-0581/2021.6/13 [in Ukrainian].
Chalabiieva, M. R. (2021). Pozytyvnyi dosvid tsyfrovizatsii krain Yevropeiskoho Soiuzu [Positive experience of digitalization of the countries of the European Union]. Ukraina i Yevropeiskyi Soiuz: shliakh do staloho rozvytku : zb. nauk. st. za mat-lamy V Vseukr. nauk.-prakt. konf. z yevrop. prava (Kharkiv, 12.11.2021). Kharkiv. URL: https://ndipzir.org.ua/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/Conf_12.11.21. pdf [in Ukrainian].
Chornous, Yu. M. (2017). Kryminalistychne zabezpechennia rozsliduvannia zlochyniv [Forensic support for the investigation of crimes]: monohrafiia. Vinnytsia. URL: http://elar.naiau.kiev.ua/ handle/123456789/16029 [in Ukrainian].
Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the European Council, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions — Coordinated Plan on Artificial Intelligence (COM(2018) 795 final) / European Commission. URL: https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/ en/library/coordinated-plan-artificial-intelligence.
Communication from the commission to the European Parliament, the European Council, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions. Artificial Intelligence for Europe. (COM/2018/237 final). Brussels, 25.4.2018 / EUR-Lex. URL: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/ EN/TXT/?uri=COM:2018:237:FIN.
Domashenko, O. M. (2019). Problemni pytannia vykorystannia tsyfrovykh dokaziv u kryminalistytsi [Problematic issues of using digital evidence in forensics]. Innovatsiini metody ta tsyfrovi tekhnolohii v kryminalistytsi, sudovii ekspertyzi ta yurydychnii praktytsi : mat-ly mizhnar. «kruhl. stolu» (Kharkiv, 12.12.2019). Kharkiv. URL: https://ivpz. kh.ua/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/%D 0%97%D0%B1%D1%96%D1%80%D0% BD-%D0%9A%D1%80%D1%83%D0%B3%D0%BB%D0%B8%D0%B9-%D1%81% D1%82%D1%96%D0%BB_%D0%86%D0%BD%D0%BD%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0% B0%D1%86%D1%96%D0%B9%D0%BD%D1%96-%D0%BC%D0%B5%D1%82%D 0%BE%D0%B4%D0%B8_2019-%D0%97 %D0%B1%D1%96%D1%80%D0%BD%D 0%B8%D0%BA.pdf [in Ukrainian].
Dufeniuk, O. (2022). Investigation of war crimes in Ukraine: challenges, standards, innovations. Baltic Journal of Legal and Social Sciences. № 1. DOI: 10.30525/2592-8813-2022-1-6 [in Ukrainian].
Dufeniuk, O. M. (2022). War crimes investigation: logistics, forensic science and medical issues. Yurydychnyi naukovyi elektronnyi zhurnal. № 4. DOI: 10.32782/2524-0374/2022-4/88 [in Ukrainian].
Dumchykov, M. (2020). The processes of digitization and forensics: a retrospective analysis. Criminalistics and Forensics. No 65. DOI: 10.33994/kndise.2020.65.10 [in Ukrainian].
European ethical Charter on the use of Artificial Intelligence in judicial systems and their environment. Аdopted at the 31st plenary meeting of the CEPEJ (Strasbourg, 3—4 December 2018) / Council of Europe. URL: https://rm.coe. int/ethical-charter-en-for-publication-4-december-2018/16808f699c.
European Parliament resolution of 16 February 2017 with recommendations to the Commission on Civil Law Rules on Robotics (2015/2103(INL)). Official Journal of the European Union. 18.7.2018. URL: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:52017I P0051&rid=9.
Europos Komisija „Priedas prie Komisijos komunikato Europos Parlamentui, Europos Vadovų Tarybai, Tarybai, Europos ekonomikos ir socialinių reikalų komitetui ir Regionų komitetui Europos požiūrio į dirbtinį intelektą formavimas“ / EUR-Lex, 2018 m. balandžio 25 d., 237 galutinis, žiūrėta 2023 m. URL: https:// eurlex.europa.eu/legal-content/LT/ TXT/?uri=COM:2018:237:FIN.
Europos Komisija „Feasibility study on a forecasting and early warning tool for migration based on artificial intelligence technology“ / Europos Sąjungos leidinių biuras Ecorys, 2021 m. vasario 15 d., žiūrėta 2023 m. URL: https:// op.europa.eu/lt/publication-detail/-/publication/5afa29f0-700a-11eb-9ac9-01aa75ed71a1/languageen/format-PDF/ source-191372680.
Fedorenko, O. A., Striltsiv, O. M., Tarasen-ko, O. S. (2022). Vykorystannia tekhnolohii shtuchnoho intelektu u pravookhoronnii diialnosti. Analitychnyi ohliad [Use of artificial intelligence technologies in law enforcement activities: Analytical review]. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Freeman, L. (2018). Digital Evidence and War Crimes Prosecutions: The Impact of Digital Technologies on International Criminal Investigations and Trials. Fordham International Law Journal. No. 41. Is. 2. URL: https://ir.lawnet. fordham.edu/ilj/vol41/iss2/1.
Hlobenko, H. I. (2021). Information and telecommunication system of pre-trial investigation: international experience and ways of implementation. Bulletin of Kharkiv National University of Internal Affairs. No 95(4). DOI: 10.32631/v.2021.4.16 [in Ukrainian].
Idder, A., Coulaux, S. (2021). Artificial intelligence in criminal justice: invasion or revolution? / International Bar Association. 13.12.2021. URL: https:// www.ibanet.org/dec-21-ai-criminal-justice.
Jackson, C. (2021). Artificial Intelligence Changing the World of Forensics Science. EasyChair Preprint. No. 5815. URL: https://easychair.org/publications/ preprint/1Fmk.
Kaplina, O. V. (2022). Military justice in the focus of the European Court of human rights. Scientific Bulletin of Public and Private Law. No 2. DOI: 10.32844/2618-1258.2022.2.29 [in Ukrainian].
Karmaza, O. O., Fedorenko, T. V. (2021). Principles of artificial intelligence in the justice of Ukraine. Law and Society. № 2. DOI: 10.32842/2078-3736/2021.2.3 [in Ukrainian].
Karmaza, O., Koucherets, D. (2021). Artificial intelligence in the civil process: prospects for use. The latest development of the modern legal sciences and education in Ukraine and EU countries: an experience, challenges, expectations : сollective monograph. Riga. DOI: 10.30525/978-9934-26-033-9-14.
Kohutych, I. (2020). Some challenges of forensic science and the methods of its formation. Criminalistics and Forensics. Vyp. 65. DOI: 10.33994/kndise.2020.65.01 [in Ukrainian].
Kohutych, I. I. (2021). Zastosuvannia tsyfrovykh tekhnolohiy — novyy napriam kryminalistyky [Application of digital technologies — a new direction of forensics]. Naukovi chytannia pamiati Hansa Hrossa : zb. tez mizhnar. nauk.-prakt. konf. (Chernivtsi, 09.12.2021). Chernivtsi [in Ukrainian].
Kolodina, A. S., Fedorova T. S. (2022). Digital forensics: problems of theory and practice. Kyiv Law Journal. No 1. DOI: 10.32782/klj/2022.1.27 [in Ukrainian].
Komisijos Komunikatas Europos Parlamentui, Tarybai, Europos Ekonomikos ir Socialinių Reikalų Komitetui ir Regionų Komitetui 2030 m. skaitmeninės politikos kelrodis : Europos skaitmeninio dešimtmečio kelias (COM(2021) 118 final). Briuselis, 2021.03.09 / Infolex. URL: https://www. infolex.lt/teise/default.aspx?id=1929&cr d=1243617&qi=7005421.
Komisijos Komunikatas Europos Parlamentui, Tarybai, Europos Ekonomikos ir Socialinių reikalų Komitetui ir Regionų Komitetui. Europos požiūrio į dirbtinį intelektą formavimas (COM(2021) 205 final). Briuselis, 2021.04.21 / Infolex. URL: https://www.infolex.lt/teise/ default.aspx?id=1929&crd=1245300.
Konovalova, V. О., Shevchuk, V. M. (2022). Modern criminalistics in the conditions of war: problems of adaptation and reload. Modern research in world science : Proceedings of the 5th International scientific and practical conference (August 7—9, 2022). Lviv. URL: https://sci-conf.com.ua/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/MODERN-RESEARCH-IN-WORLD-SCIENCE-7-9.08.2022.pdf.
Kosilova, O. I., Rozghon, O. V., Solodovniko-vа, C. K., Stolbovyi, V. M., Barabash, O. O. (2022). Observance of Human Rights in the Use of AI as Technology. Law, State and Telecommunications Review. Vol. 14. No. 2. DOI: 10.26512/lstr.v14i2.41558.
Kovtun, V. O., Rvachov, O. M. (2020). Ohliad ta perspektyvy vykorystannia tekhnolohiy shtuchnoho intelektu v pravookhoronniy̆ diialnosti [Overview and prospects of using artificial intelligence technologies in law enforcement]. Vykorystannia tekhnolohii shtuchnoho intelektu u protydii zlochynnosti : mat-ly nauk.-prakt. onlayn-seminaru (Kharkiv, 05.11.2020). Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].
Kozhevnikova, A. (2022). The use of artificial intelligence in the civil process. Scientific Bulletin of the International Humanities University. Series: Jurisprudence. № 55. DOI: 10.32841/2307-1745.2022.55.9 [in Ukrainian].
Krytska, I. O. (2020). «Dorizhka tsyfrovykh slidiv»: dokazove znachennia y okremi aspekty zbyrannia ta doslidzhennia u kryminalnomu provadzhenni [Digital footprint trail: evidentiary value and separate aspects of collection and research in criminal proceedings]. Tsyfrovi transformatsii Ukrainy 2020: vyklyky ta realii : zb. nauk. pr. NDI PZIR NAPrN Ukrainy № 1 za mat-my kruhl. stolu (Kharkiv, 18.09.2020). Kharkiv. URL: https://ndipzir.org.ua/wp-content/ uploads/2020/12/Tezy_18_09_2020_17. pdf [in Ukrainian].
Kryvoruchko, O., Bebeshko, B., Khorolska, K., Desiatko, A., Kotenko, N. (2020). Artificial intelligence face recognition for authentication. Technical Sciences and Technology. № 2 (20). URL: http://tst.stu. cn.ua/article/view/215780.
Kryvytskyi, Yu. (2021). Artificial Intelligence as a Tool of Legal Reform: Potential, Trends and Prospects. Scientific Journal of the National Academy of Internal Affairs. 26(2). DOI: 10.33270/01211192.90.
Kurapka, V. Eh., Malevski, G. (2019). Nauchnaia kontseptsiia kriminalisticheskoi politiki v strategiiakh organov pravoporiadka kak innovatsionnyi proryv v obespechenii sozdaniia obshchego evropeiskogo kriminalisticheskogo prostranstva [Scientific concept of forensic policy in the strategies of law enforcement agencies as an innovative breakthrough in the creation of a common European forensic space]. Innovatsiini metody ta tsyfrovi tekhnolohii v kryminalistytsi, sudovii ekspertyzi ta yurydychnii praktytsi : mat-ly mizhnar. «kruhl. stolu» (Kharkiv, 12.12.2019). Kharkiv. URL: https://ivpz. kh.ua/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/%D 0%97%D0%B1%D1%96%D1%80%D0%BD-%D0%9A%D1%80%D1%83%D0%B3 %D0%BB%D0%B8%D0%B9-%D1%81%D1%82%D1%96%D0%BB_%D0%86%D0 %BD%D0%BD%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%B0%D1%86%D1%96%D0%B9%D0%BD%D1%96-%D0%BC%D0%B5%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%B4%D0%B8_2019-%D0%97 %D0%B1%D1%96%D1%80%D0%BD%D 0%B8%D0%BA.pdf [in Russian].
Latysh, K. (2022). Tsyfrova kryminalistyka u period viyny v Ukraini: mozhlyvosti vykorystannia spetsialnykh znan u sferi informatsiynykh tekhnolohiy [Digital Forensics During the War in Ukraine: Possibilities of Using Special Knowledge in the Field of Information Technologies]. Kriminalistikairteismo ekspertologija : mokslas, studijos, praktika. T. 18. URL: https://repository.mruni.eu/ bitstream/handle/007/18524/XVIII%20 Vilnius%202022_compressed-18-21. pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y [in Ukrainian].
Malevski, H., Kurapka, V. E., Tamelė, I. (2021). Motivation and expectations of students — an important factor in the implementation of the new bachelor’s degreeprogram “Law and Criminalistics”. The Criminalist of the First Printing. № 21—22.
Manzhai, O. V., Potylchak A. O. (2020). Crime mapping features. Law and Safety. No 79 (4). DOI: 10.32631/pb.2020.4.10 [in Ukrainian].
Michurin, I. O. (2020). Legal Nature of Artificial Intelligence [Legal nature of artificial intelligence]. Forum Prava. No 64 (5). DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.4300624 [in Ukrainian].
Mosov, S. P., Khoroshylova, S. Y. (2018). Osoblyvosti zastosuvannia stratehichnoi bezpilotnoi rozviduvalnoi aviatsii u voiennykh konfliktakh XXI stolittia [Peculiarities of the use of strategic unmanned reconnaissance aircraft in military conflicts of the XXI century]. Zbirnyk naukovykh prats Tsentru voienno-stratehichnykh doslidzhen Natsionalnoho universytetu oborony Ukrainy imeni Ivana Cherniakhovskoho. № 2 (63). URL: http:// nbuv.gov.ua/UJRN/Znpcvsd_2018_2_19 [in Ukrainian].
Movchan, A., Movchan, M. (2020). Use of unlimited aerial vehicles in the activities of law enforcement agencies. Sоcial & Legal Studios. No 3 (9). DOI: 10.32518/2617-4162-2020-3-104-110 [in Ukrainian].
Musiienko, O. L. (2019). Vykorystannia tsyfrovykh tekhnolohiy pry rozsliduvanni zlochyniv [The use of digital technologies in the investigation of crimes]. Innovatsiini metody ta tsyfrovi tekhnolohii v kryminalistytsi, sudovii ekspertyzi ta yurydychnii praktytsi : mat-ly mizhnar. «kruhl. stolu» (Kharkiv, 12.12.2019). Kharkiv. URL: https://ivpz.kh.ua/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/%D0%97%D0% B1%D1%96%D1%80%D0%BD-%D0%9A %D1%80%D1%83%D0%B3%D0%BB%D0%B8%D0%B9-%D1%81%D1%82%D1% 96%D0%BB_%D0%86%D0%BD%D0%BD%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%B0%D1%86%D 1%96%D0%B9%D0%BD%D1%96-%D0%BC%D0%B5%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%B4 %D0%B8_2019-%D0%97%D0%B1%D1%96%D1%80%D0%BD%D0%B8%D0%BA. pdf [in Ukrainian].
Myslyvyi, V. A. (2020). Shtuchnyi intelekt yak faktor zapobihannia dorozhno-transportnoi zlochynnosti [Artificial intelligence as a factor in the prevention of traffic crime]. Vykorystannia tekhnolohii shtuchnoho intelektu u protydii zlochynnosti : mat-ly nauk.-prakt. onlain-seminaru (Kharkiv, 05.11.2020). Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].
Petryshyn, O. V., Hyliaka, O. S. (2021). Human rights in the digital age: Challenges, threats and prospects. Journal of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine. Vol. 28. No. 1. DOI: 10.37635/ jnalsu.28(1).2021.15-23.
Pistrakevych, O. V. (2021). Stratehii rozvytku shtuchnoho intelektu v Yevropeiskomu Soiuzi (na prykladi krain Vyshehradskoi hrupy [Strategies for the development of artificial intelligence in the European Union (on the example of the countries of the Visegrad Group)]. Mizhnarodni vidnosyny, suspilni komunikatsii ta rehionalni studii. № 1 (9). URL: https://elibrary.kubg.edu.ua/ id/eprint/39141/1/O_Pistrakevych_ IRPCRS_1%289%29_2021.pdf [in Ukrainian].
Pylypchuk, V. G., Baranov, O. A., Gilyaka, O. S. (2022). The problem of legal regulation in the field of artificial intelligence in the context of the development of the legislation of the European Union. Journal of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine. Т. 29. № 2. DOI: 10.37635/jnalsu.29(2).2022.35-62 [in Ukrainian].
Radutniy, O. E. (2020). Novel Criminal Delicts Related to Digital Human Being. Herald of the Association of Criminal Law of Ukraine. Т. 1. № 13. URL: http://vakp.nlu.edu.ua/ issue/view/12594.
Recommendation of the Council on Artificial Intelligence / OECD Legal Instruments. URL: https://legalinstruments.oecd.org/ en/instruments/OECD-LEGAL-0449.
%D1%80%D0%BD%D0%B8%D0%BA. pdf [in Ukrainian].
Shepitko, V. (2021). Theoretical and methodological model of criminalistics and its new directions. Theory and Practice of Forensic Science and Criminalistics. 25(3). DOI: 10.32353/khrife.3.2021.02.
Shepitko, V. Yu. (2022). Formuvannia doktryny kryminalistyky ta sudovoi ekspertyzy v Ukraini — shliakh do yedynoho yevropeiskoho kryminalistychnoho prostoru [Formation of the doctrine of criminalistics and forensics in Ukraine — the way to a single European forensic space]. Pravo Ukrainy. № 2 [in Ukrainian].
Shepitko, V. Yu., Shepitko, M. V. (2021). The role of forensic science and forensic examination in international cooperation in the investigation of crimes. Journal of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine. Vol. 28. Iss. 1. DOI: 10.37635/ jnalsu.28(1).2021.179-186.
Shepitko, V., Shepitko, M. (2021). Doktryna kryminalistyky ta sudovoi ekspertyzy: formuvannia, suchasnyi stan i rozvytok v Ukraini [Doctrine of criminology and forensic examination: formation, current state and development in Ukraine]. Pravo Ukrainy. № 8 [in Ukrainian].
Shepitko, V., Shepitko, M. (2021). Formuvannia tsyfrovoi kryminalistyky yak stratehichnyi napriamok rozvytku nauky [The Formation of Digital Criminalistics as a Strategic Direction for the Development of Science]. Kriminalistika a Forenzne Vedy: Veda, Vzdelavanie, Prax : 17 Medzinarodny Kongres Zbornik Prispevkov (16— 17 sept 2021, Bratislava, Slovenská republika). Bratislava. URL: https:// www.akademiapz.sk/sites/default/files/ KKFV/2020/CrimCongres2021 zborník draft digit v6 202107.pdf [in Ukrainian].
Shevchuk, V. M. (2020). Perspektyvy zaprovadzhennia tekhnolohii shtuchnoho intelektu u sudovu diialnist v suchasnykh umovakh [Prospects for the introduction of artificial intelligence in judicial activity in modern conditions]. Vykorystannia tekhnolohii shtuchnoho intelektu u protydii zlochynnosti : mat-ly nauk.-prakt. onlayn-seminaru (Kharkiv, 05.11.2020). Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].
Shevchuk, V. M. (2022). Tsyfrova kryminalistyka: formuvannia ta rol u zabezpechenni bezpekovoho seredovyshcha Ukrainy [Digital forensics: formation and role in ensuring the security environment of Ukraine]. Nova arkhitektura bezpekovoho seredovyshcha Ukrainy : zb. tez Vseukr. nauk.-prakt. konf. (Kharkiv, 23.12.2022). Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].
Shevchuk, V. M. (2022). Tsyfrova kryminalistyka: voienni vyklyky sohodennia ta novi zavdannia u su-chasnykh umovakh [Digital forensics: military challenges of today and new tasks in modern conditions]. Pravovi vyklyky suchasnosti : mat-ly Vseukr. kruhloho stolu (Kharkiv, 20.12.2022). Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].
Shevchuk, V. M. (2022). Yevropeiskyi vektor rozvytku suchasnoi kryminalistyky [European vector of modern forensics development]. Adaptatsiia pravovoi systemy Ukrainy do prava Yevropeiskoho Soiuzu: teoretychni ta praktychni aspekty : mat-ly Vseukr. nauk.-prakt. konf. z nahody 20-yi richn. stvor. Poltav. yuryd. in-tu NIuU im. Yaroslava Mudroho (Poltava, 29.09.2022). Poltava. URL: http://pli.nlu.edu.ua/wp-content/ uploads/2022/12/Zbirnyk-29.09.pdf [in Ukrainian].
Stepaniuk, R., Perlin, S. (2022). Digital forensics and improvement of the forensic technology system in Ukraine. Bulletin of Luhansk State University of Internal Affairs Named After E. Didorenko. 3(99). DOI: 10.33766/2524-0323.99.283-284 [in Ukrainian].
Striltsiv, O. M., Fedorenko, O. A. (2022). Problems of legal regulation of the use of artificial intelligence technologies by the National Police of Ukraine. Scientific Journal of the National Academy of Internal Affairs. Vol. 27. No. 1. DOI: 10.33270/0122271.30.
Textbook of criminalistics (2016). Vol. 1: General theory / Ed. by H. Malevski, V. Shepitko. Kharkiv.
Tokar, L. V. (2020). Shtuchnyy intelekt na varti spravedlyvosti: utopiia chy perspektyva liudstva [Artificial intelligence as guard of justice: utopia or the prospect of humanity]. Porivnialno-analitychne pravo. № 2. URL: https://dspace.uzhnu.edu.ua/jspui/bitstream/lib/35614/1/%d0%a8%d0%a2%d0%a3%d0%a7%d0%9d% d0%98%d0%99%20%d0%86%d0%9d%d0%a2%d0%95%d0%9b%d0%95%d0 %9a%d0%a2%20%d0%9d%d0%90%20 % d 0 % 9 2 % d 0 % 9 0 % d 0 % a 0 % d 0 % -a2%d0%86%20%d0%a1%d0%9f%d0%a0%d0%90%d0%92%d0%95%d0%94%d0% 9b%d0%98%d0%92%d0%9e%d0%a1%d 0%a2%d0%86.pdf [in Ukrainian].
Tokarieva, K., Savliva, N. (2021). Peculiarities of legal regulation of artificial intelligence in Ukraine. Scientific Works of National Aviation University. Series: Law Journal «Air and Space Law». 3 (60). DOI: 10.18372/2307-9061.60.15967 [in Ukrainian].
Turuta, O., Turuta, O. (2022). Artificial intelligence through the prism of fundamental human rights. Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law. No 71. DOI: 10.24144/2307-3322.2022.71.7 [in Ukrainian].
Tymoshenko, Y. P., Kozachenko, O. I., Kyslenko, D. P., Horodetska, M. S., Chubata, M. V., Barhan, S. S. (2022). Latest technologies in criminal investigation (testing of foreign practices in Ukraine). Amazonia Investiga. Vol. 11. No. 51. DOI: 10.34069/AI/2022.51.03.14.
Vebb, E. (2020). Velyka deviatka. Yak IT-hihanty ta yikhni rozumni mashyny mozhut zminyty liudstvo [The Big Nine: How the Tech Titans and Their Thinking Machines Could Warm Humanity]/ per. z anhl. I. Vozniaka. Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].
Velykanova, М. М. (2020). Artificial intelligence: legal problems and risks. Journal of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine. Vol. 27. No. 4. DOI: 10.37635/jnalsu.27(4).2020.185-198.
Von der Leyen, U. A Union that strives for more. My agenda for Europe / European Commission. URL: https://www. europarl.europa.eu/resources/library/ media/20190716RES57231/20190716R ES57231.pdf.
White Paper on Artificial Intelligence: a European approach to excellence and trust / European Commission. URL: https://commission.europa.eu/ publications/white-paper-artificial-i nt el l i ge n c e - e u rop ean - app ro a ch -excellence-and-trust_en.
Yurtaieva, K. V. (2020). Vykorystannia tekhnolohii shtuchnoho intelektu v realizatsii stratehii «predictive polic-ing»: mozhlyvosti, problemy ta perspektyvy dlia Ukrainy [The use of artificial intelligence in the implementation of «predictive policing»: opportunities, problems and prospects for Ukraine]. Vykorystannia tekhnolohii shtuchnoho intelektu u protydii zlochynnos-ti : nauk.-prakt. seminar (Kharkiv, 05.11.2020). Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].
Zhuravel, V. A. (2021). Zahalna teoriia kryminalistyky: geneza ta suchasnyi stan [General theory of criminology: genesis and current state]: monohrafiia. Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].
Zhuravel, V. A., Konovalova, V. E., Avdeyeva, G. К. (2021). Reliability Evaluation of a Forensic Expert’s Opinion: World Practices and Ukrainian Realities. Journal of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine. Vol. 28. No. 2. DOI: 10.37635/jnalsu.28(2).2021.252-261.
Zhuravel, V. A., Shepitko, V. Yu. (2021). Rozvytok kryminalistyky ta sudovoi ekspertyzy v Ukraini: nablyzhennia do yedynoho yevropeiskoho prostoru [Development of Criminalistics and Forensics in Ukraine: Approaching a Single European Space]/ Pravova nauka Ukrainy: suchasnyi stan, vyklyky ta perspektyvy rozvytku : monohrafiia. Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].
