THE PROBLEM OF SUBCLASS CHARACTERISTICS WHILE EXAMINATION OF REDESIGNED FLARE GUNS
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32353/khrife.1.2020_22Keywords:
common characteristics, individual characteristics, subclass characteristics, identity, forensic firearm examinationAbstract
In the process of cartridge case forensic identification common and separate (individual) characteristics are distinguished. Common characteristics are typical for a certain construction/model of firearms and are used for identifying the cartridge case group affiliation. Individual characteristics are random and are used for determining identity. Subclass characteristics appear at the stage of mechanical processing of the firearms’ parts. Therefore, the same marks can be observed on a few parts, which were consequently processed by the same tool. Lack of knowledge on the differences between individual and subclass characteristics may result in wrong conclusions as to identity.
The article purpose is to acquaint ballistic forensic experts with the problem of subclass characteristics, mechanism of their occurrence and the ways for their determination.
The mechanism of subclass characteristics occurrence and the characteristics on the basis of which we can determine that the examined characteristic is individual or subclass are discussed. The main examples of subclass characteristics, such as lands and grooves, arches, circles for which the width, depth and relative position of each element coincide, were given. The peculiarities of scene which allow to determine the individual characteristics among subclass characteristics are presented. Such features include the presence of irregularities along the lands and grooves, which make up the subclass feature, the cross section of the lands and grooves, etc. The possibility of identifying subclass characteristics is illustrated by the real case from forensic practice while redesigned flare gun examination.
The article highlights the need regarding the ability to determine subclass characteristics and the influence of such characteristics on the possibility of drawing up a conclusion as to identity.
References
Artiushin, A. A. (2010). Kriminalisticheskoe issledovanie samodelnykh pistoletov s na- reznym stvolom pod patron kalibra 9kh19 PM, izgotovlennykh iz pnevmatich- eskikh gazoballonnykh pistoletov MR-654K. Krimіnalіstichnii vіsnik, 1 (13) [in Russian].
Clontz, J., Hearns, S., & Jaikissoon, S. (2020). Blank-Firing Devices Converted to Fire Live Ammunition: Trends Observed by the NYPD 2012 to 2018. AFTE Journal, 52 (2), 2019–2021.
Florquin, N., & King, B. (2018). Converted Firearms in Europe FROM LEGAL TO LE- THAL. Retrieved from http://www.smallarmssurvey.org/fileadmin/docs/U-Re- ports/SAS-Report-Europe-Conversion.pdf
Givertc, P. V., Kokin, A. V. (2020). Problema podklassovykh priznakov v sudebnoi bal- listike: vozniknovenie, diagnostirovanie i vliianie na identifikatciiu. Sudebnaia ekspertiza, 1 (61). https://doi.org/10.25724/VAMVD.LUVW [in Russian].
Iarmak, K. V. (2016). Problemy teorii i praktiki sudebnykh ekspertiz i issledovanii. Sudeb- naia ekspertiza. Vyp. 2, № 46 [in Russian].
King, B. (2017). Small Arms Survey — Proliferation of converted firearms in Europe [Conference proceedings]. ENFSI Firearms/GSR 24th Annual Meeting, 19. Es- poo, Finland, October 11th — 13th.
Kokin, A. V. (2015). Prakticheskie aspekty issledovaniia pul, vystrelennykh iz samodel- nogo oruzhiia. Vestnik Nizhegorodskogo universiteta im. N.I. Lobachevskogo, 1 [in Russian].
Kokin, A. V., Iarmak, K. V. (2018). Sudebnaia ballistika i sudebno-ballisticheskaia ek- spertiza. Moscow: Moskovskii universitet MVD Rossii imeni V. Ia. Kikotia [in Russian].
Kramer, S. (2012). Subclass Characteristics on Firing Pins Manufactured by “Metal Injec- tion Molding.” AFTE Journal, 44 (4).
Lee, M., Burritt, M., Karsten, R., Wickwire, J., & Jeffrey, A. (2016). Subclass Carryover in Smith & Wesson M & P 15-22 Rifle Firing Pins. AFTE Journal, 48(1).
Lightstone, L. (2010). The Potential for and Persistence of Subclass Chracteristics on the Breech Faces of SW40VE Smith & Wesson Sigma Pistols. AFTE Journal, 42(4).
Lopez, L. L., & Grew, S. (2000). Consecutively machined ruger bolt faces. AFTE Journal, 32(2).
Melnik, R. V. (2013). Osobennosti mekhanizma obrazovaniia sledov na gilzakh i snari- adakh, strelianykh iz peredelannogo ognestrelnogo oruzhiia. Matters of Rassian and International Law, 2. [in Russian].
Melnik, R. V. (2013). Poperedni sudovo-balistychni doslidzhennia obiektiv pereroblenykh u vohnepalnu zbroiu. Visnyk Luhanskoho derzhavnoho universytetu vnutrishnikh sprav imeni E.O. Didorenka, 1 [in Ukrainian].
Melnik, R. V. (2014). Pevni osoblyvosti kryminalistychnoho doslidzhennia samorobnoi ta pereroblenoi vohnepalnoi zbroi. Kryminalistychnyi visnyk, 1 (21) [in Ukrainian]. Melnik, R. V. (2016). Doslidzhennia vohnepalnoi zbroi, pereroblenykh z maketiv maso- habarytnykh (MMH) ta yikh slidy na kuliakh ta hilzakh. Informatsiino-dovidkovyi
posibnyk. Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].
Melnik, R. V. (2017). Teoretychni ta praktychni aspekty kryminalistychnoho doslidzhen- nia obiektiv, pereroblenykh u vohnepalnu zbroiu (CNL). Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].
Melnyk, R. V., Hamera, V. A., Tolochyn, D. V. (2016). Deiaki osoblyvosti kryminalistych- noho doslidzhennia samorobnoi ta pereroblennoi vohnepalnoi zbroi. Porivnial- no-analitychne pravo. Vyp. 4 [in Ukrainian].
Monturo, C. (2019). Forensic Firearm Examination. Academic Press.
Nichols, R. (2018). Firearm and toolmark identification: the scientific reliability of the forensic science discipline. Academic Press.
Nies, R. (2003). Anvil Marks of the Ruger MKII Target Pistol – An Example of Subclass Characteristics. AFTE Journal, 35(1).
Pereira, N. (2011). A decade of converted pistols in Portugal [Conference proceedings]. ENFSI Firearms/GSR 18th Annual Meeting, 31. Lisbon, Portugal, October 25th- 28th.
Rivera, G. (2007). Subclass Characteristics in Smith & Wesson SW40VE Sigma Pistols.
AFTE Journal, 39(3).
Skae, A. (2007). Recent Trends in Converted Firearms in England and Wales [Conference proceedings]. ENFSI Firearms/GSR 14th Annual Meeting, 4. Prague, CZ, 5th – 8th September.
TR17 Blank Firing Gun. Retrieved June 28, 2020, from Zira Silah. website: https://www. zirasilah.com.tr/en/tr17-blank-firing-gun/28.
Tulleners, F. A., & Hamiel, J. (1999). Sub Class Characteristins of Sequentially Rifled 38 Special S&W Revolver Barrels. AFTE Journal, 31(2).
Welch, A. K. (2013). Breech Face Subclass Characteristics of the Jimenez JA Nine Pistol.
AFTE Journal, 45(4).
