Plea Bargaining — A Comparative Study of India with Foreign Countries


Keywords: pre-trial concessions; negotiations; plea bargaining; punishment; Law Commission; judicial system.

Abstract

Plea bargaining has become more popular as a means of settling court issues all around the world. Plea bargaining’s application, scope, and operation change significantly between common law and civil law regimes. To analyze these differences in regard to different jurisdictions, a comparison between India and the USA (their plea bargaining) has been done in this study. The relative benefits and drawbacks of plea bargaining are up for debate. This is because it is argued that plea bargaining calls into question the primary goals of a trial, which are to establish the truth and uphold justice. It is without dispute that India needs a framework for speedy justice administration. Indian courts are being battered by the rise in criminal cases. Prisons are now overflowing with inmates who are being held without a trial due to the ongoing delays in case resolution. India has developed plea bargaining (as a response to this sad status of the judicial system), which was acknowledged as a trustworthy strategy for concluding open cases and accelerating the criminal justice system. According to the then-Chief Justice of India, Y. K. Sabharwal (2005-2007), the introduction of plea bargaining in India would not only expedite the criminal justice system but also serve as a restorative form of justice where victims would be equal stakeholders and receive sufficient compensation. However, despite years of conceptualization, the Indian criminal justice system has yet to adopt plea bargaining. The paper attempts to research whether plea bargaining in India in its present form and structure is adequate to achieve that goal by weighing its advantages and disadvantages in the context of the Indian judicial system. Given the above, it is proposed to introduce changes to this contemporary dispute resolution mechanism.

References

Aggarwal, T., Rewari, S. (2006). Wanna Make
a Deal? The Introduction of Plea Bargaining in India. URL: https://www.ebc-india.com/ lawyer/articles/2006_2cri_12.htm.
Alschuler, A. W. (1979). Plea Bargaining and its History. Law & Society Review. Vol. 13. No. 2. Special Issue on Plea Bargaining. DOI: 10.2307/3053250.
Bhattacharjee, A. Indian Laws on Plea-bargain-ing Anwesha Bhattacharjee / Lawyers Club India. URL: https://www.lawyersclubindia. com/articles/Indian-Laws-on-Plea-bargain-ing-4213.asp.
Black’s Law Dictionary (1999) / ed. B. A. Garner. West Publishing Company, 7th Ed.
Chandrasekharan Pillai, K. N. (2008). R. V. Kelkar’s Criminal Procedure. Eastern Book Company.
Cheesman, S. J. A Comparative Analysis of Plea Bargaining and the Subsequent Tensions with an Effective and Fair Legal Defence. Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Szeged. URL: http://doktori.bibl.u-sze-ged.hu/2488/1/Samantha_Joy_Cheesman_ ertekezes.pdf.
Goode, E. (2012). Stronger Hand for Judges in the ‘Bazaar’ of Plea Deals / The New York Times. URL: https://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/23/ us/stronger-hand-for-judges-after-rulings-on-plea-deals.html.
Iovene, F. (2013). Plea Bargaining and Abbreviated Trial in Italy. Warwick School of Law Research Paper. No. 2013/11. DOI: 10.2139/ ssrn.2286705.
Kathuria, S. (2007).The Bargain has been Struck: A Case For Plea Bargaining in India. Special Issue on Alternative Dispute Resolution in Association with the Singhania Chair on ADR Laws. Vol. 19. No. 2.
LaFave, W. R. et al. (2007). 5 Criminal Procedure § 21.3(f) at 769 (West 3d ed.).
Messitte, P. J. (2010). Plea Bargaining in Various Criminal Justice Systems. Conf. Montevideo, Uruguay (May, 2010). URL: https://www.law.ufl.edu/_pdf/academics/centers/cgr/11th_ conference/Peter_Messitte_Plea_Bargain-ing.pdf.
Pizzi, W., Marafioti, L. (1992). The New Italian Code of Criminal Procedure: The Difficulties of Building an Adversarial Trial System on a Civil Law Foundation. Yale Journal of International Law. Is. 1. Art. 2. Vol. 17. URL: https://openyls.law.yale.edu/han-dle/20.500.13051/6264.
Randhwa, G. S. (2015). Victimology and Compensatory Jurisprudence. Central Law Publications. Vishwanath, A. Why hasn’t Plea Bargaining taken Off in India? / Mint. URL: https:// www.livemint.com/Politics/otm5XvV7DTZ-J9KaKScbJ4H/Why-hasnt-plea-bargaining-taken-off-in-India.html.

Abstract views: 226
PDF Downloads: 142
Published
2023-04-18
How to Cite
Majumder, B. (2023). Plea Bargaining — A Comparative Study of India with Foreign Countries. Theory and Practice of Forensic Science and Criminalistics, 29(4), 47-67. https://doi.org/10.32353/khrife.4.2022.03